Elon Musk Says "I'm Not MAGA" and Regrets Spending Nearly $500 Million — Was He Right to Walk Away?


Elon Musk has said a lot of extraordinary things in public. What he said on Wednesday, November 18, may be the most politically consequential of them all. Speaking by video link from China at the New York Times DealBook Summit, in conversation with Andrew Ross Sorkin, the world's richest man looked back on his enormous political spending in the 2026 midterms — and said he regrets it. And then, in the same conversation, he said the words that lit up every news feed in America: "I'm not MAGA."

But — and this matters more than the headline — he qualified it, immediately and carefully. "I'm not sure what MAGA means," he said, "but if that means sort of blind adherence to a set of policies by the Republican Party, then I certainly don't have that." That is not the same as a flat break. It is not a denunciation. It is a man drawing a line around what he will and will not sign up for, and telling the world where that line sits. If you read only the three-word quote, you will misunderstand the story. If you read the whole sentence, you will understand it.

And the money part is just as striking. "I feel pretty foolish about having spent so much money and not seeing much for it," Musk said, talking about his midterm spending. The scale of that spending is hard to grasp. According to OpenSecrets, the nonpartisan tracker of money in politics, Musk put at least four hundred and forty-five million dollars behind Republicans this cycle. News reports have rounded that figure to nearly five hundred million dollars. Either way, it is one of the largest political spending sprees by a single individual in American history — and by Musk's own account, it did not buy what he hoped it would buy. Democrats took control of Congress in the midterms.

So tonight, we are asking you the question that follows naturally from all of this: was Musk right to walk away — YES or NO? Before you answer, let us lay out the full story, because the context changes everything.

Who is Elon Musk, and how did he get here?

For readers who know him mainly as the man behind the rockets and the electric cars, a quick recap. Musk is the chief executive of Tesla and SpaceX, the owner of X, and the richest person in the world. His companies build electric cars, launch rockets that land themselves, and run the satellite internet network Starlink. He is not a politician. He has never held office. But in the last few years he has become one of the most powerful political figures in America without ever being on a ballot — through his money, his platform, and his willingness to say what other billionaires only think.

In 2024, he went further than any of that. He called himself "dark, gothic MAGA," campaigned alongside Donald Trump, appeared at rallies, and put his money and his platform behind the Republican cause. He was not a donor on the sidelines — he was in the arena, on stage. That is what makes Wednesday's words so remarkable: the man who once dressed the part is now telling the world he does not belong to the movement, or at least not to the version that demands blind adherence.

What is the DealBook Summit?

The setting matters, because it explains the tone. The DealBook Summit is the New York Times' annual gathering of business and political leaders, where chief executives talk candidly on stage. Musk was speaking by video link from China, interviewed by Andrew Ross Sorkin, the Times columnist who runs DealBook. The format — a long, live conversation rather than a scripted speech — is where Musk tends to say what he actually thinks, and both the regret line and the MAGA line came out unscripted.

The fact that he was speaking from China adds another layer. Tesla's Shanghai factory is one of its most important plants, so Musk was a businessman in Beijing talking to an American audience about American politics — a tightrope almost no other person on earth walks.

What did he actually spend — $445 million or $500 million?

Let us be careful with the numbers, because both figures are in circulation and both are correct in their own way. OpenSecrets, which tracks political spending from public filings, puts the tally at at least four hundred and forty-five million dollars behind Republican candidates and causes this cycle. That is the sourced, documented number — the floor, based on what has been disclosed. News reports, adding in spending that is harder to trace and rounding for headlines, have described it as nearly five hundred million dollars. We are using both figures the way the reporting does: four hundred and forty-five million as the OpenSecrets tally, nearly five hundred million as the rounded figure. The difference between them is less important than the scale of either one. Half a billion dollars, spent by one man, on one election cycle. And by his own account, it did not work.

What did it not buy? Control of Congress. Democrats took control in the midterms — the very outcome Musk's spending was meant to prevent. That is the context for "I feel pretty foolish about having spent so much money and not seeing much for it." He is not saying money does not matter in politics. He is saying his money did not deliver the result he paid for.

Why does this matter beyond Musk?

Because Musk is not just any donor. He is the test case for a new kind of political power: the billionaire who owns the platform, funds the campaigns, and speaks directly to tens of millions of people every day. If the richest man in the world, spending more than almost anyone in history, cannot buy the outcome he wants, that tells us something important about the limits of money in politics. Voters still vote. Half a billion dollars is a lot of money — but it is not a remote control for a democracy.

It also matters because of what it signals for the next election. Musk walking away — or even half-walking away — leaves a hole in Republican fundraising that will be hard to fill. Other donors will watch what he does next. If he sits out the next cycle, or backs different candidates, the shape of American politics shifts. And if he changes his mind again, as he has before, that will be a story too.

What Musk saidWhat it means
"I'm not MAGA" — qualifiedNot blind adherence to Republican policies; not a flat break
"I feel pretty foolish about having spent so much money"Regret over midterm spending that did not deliver
At least $445m (OpenSecrets) / nearly $500m (reports)One of the largest single-person spending sprees ever
Democrats took control of CongressThe outcome his spending was meant to prevent
In 2024 he called himself "dark, gothic MAGA"The contrast is the story

So — was he right to walk away?

That is the question, and it is genuinely hard. On one side: half a billion dollars is an almost unimaginable amount of money to spend on politics, and if it did not work, walking away is the rational thing to do. A businessman who keeps pouring money into a failing investment is not loyal — he is stubborn. Musk built his fortune by cutting losses and moving on. Why should politics be different?

On the other side: walking away after one defeat has consequences too. The causes and candidates he supported do not disappear because he stopped writing cheques. And there is a version of this story in which the lesson is not "money doesn't work" but "money works slowly" — in which the infrastructure, the data and the platform he built pay off over years, not in a single midterm. Quitting after one cycle might be quitting too soon.

And then there is the third view, the one that does not fit neatly into YES or NO: that the real story is the man himself. Musk has always defined himself against the crowd — the outsider who does not fit in any box. "I'm not MAGA" may be less a political strategy than a personal statement: I am not yours. That has always been his brand.

So tell us, America — was Musk right to walk away? Vote YES or NO in the comments, and tell us WHY. If you think he was right, tell us what he should do with his money instead. If you think he was wrong, tell us what you would have done with half a billion dollars and a platform used by hundreds of millions. And if you voted Republican in the midterms — or Democrat — tell us what Musk's money meant to you, if it meant anything at all.

For the other big stories of the day, read our coverage of the summit in Shenzhen, Trump, Xi and Putin Meet Today in Shenzhen — Three Superpowers, One Table, Deal or Drama?, the record IPO, Anthropic IPO: AI Company Worth $1.5 Trillion Goes Public Today — Bubble or Future?, and the Fed's warning on rates, Fed Minutes Reveal More Rate Hikes Are Coming — What It Means for Your Mortgage, Loans and Savings.

Tell us in the comments: was Musk right to walk away — YES or NO?

🎬

Read Next

Watch the video version on our Dailymotion channel: https://dailymotion.com/user/autoworkflowstudio — and on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@viralnewsusa-m2b

 

Comments